Jump to content

Polyfill (programming): Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Westweg (talk | contribs)
Added another example for an polyfill; Hyphenopoly.js
Replaced GitHub reference with Ars Technica article.
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
 
(21 intermediate revisions by 14 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
{{other uses|Polyfill (disambiguation)}}
{{other uses|Polyfill (disambiguation)}}


In [[web development]], a '''polyfill''' is code that implements a feature on [[web browser]]s that do not natively support the feature. Most often, it refers to a [[JavaScript]] [[Library (computing)|library]] that implements an [[HTML5]] or [[CSS]] [[web standard]], either an established standard (supported by some browsers) on older browsers, or a proposed standard (not supported by any browsers) on existing browsers. Formally, "a polyfill is a [[Shim (computing)|shim]] for a browser [[Application programming interface|API]]."<ref name="speakingjs">{{cite book|title=Speaking JavaScript |url=http://speakingjs.com/ |author=Luis Ángel Pérez Castillo |year=2019}}</ref>
In [[software development]], a '''polyfill''' is code that implements a feature of the [[development environment]] that does not natively support the feature. Most often, it refers to [[JavaScript]] code that implements an [[HTML5]] or [[CSS]] [[web standard]], either an established standard (supported by some browsers) on older browsers, or a proposed standard (not supported by any browsers) on existing browsers. Polyfills are also used in [[PHP]] and [[Python (programming language)|Python]].<ref>{{Cite book |last=Thormeier |first=Pascal |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=yprEEAAAQBAJ&dq=polyfill+php&pg=PA195 |title=Mastering CSS Grid: A comprehensive and practical guide to creating beautiful layouts with CSS Grid |date=2023-06-09 |publisher=Packt Publishing Ltd |isbn=978-1-80461-616-1 |pages=195 |language=}}</ref>


Polyfills allow web developers to use an API regardless of whether or not it is supported by a browser, and usually with minimal overhead. Typically they first check if a browser supports an API, and use it if available, otherwise using their own implementation.<ref name="speakingjs"/><ref>"It typically checks if a browser supports an API. If it doesn’t, the polyfill installs its own implementation. That allows you to use the API in either case."</ref> Polyfills themselves use other, more supported features, and thus different polyfills may be needed for different browsers. The term is also used as a verb: ''polyfilling'' is providing a polyfill for a feature.
Polyfills allow web developers to use an API regardless of whether or not it is supported by a browser, and usually with minimal overhead. Typically they first check if a browser supports an API, and use it if available, otherwise using their own implementation.<ref name="speakingjs">{{cite book|title=Speaking JavaScript |url=http://speakingjs.com/ |author=Luis Ángel Pérez Castillo |year=2019}}</ref><ref>"It typically checks if a browser supports an API. If it doesn’t, the polyfill installs its own implementation. That allows you to use the API in either case."</ref> Polyfills themselves use other, more supported features, and thus different polyfills may be needed for different browsers. The term is also used as a verb: ''polyfilling'' is providing a polyfill for a feature.


==Definition==
==Definition==


The term is a [[neologism]], coined by Remy Sharp, who required a word that meant "replicate an API using JavaScript (or Flash or whatever) if the browser doesn’t have it natively" while co-writing the book ''Introducing HTML5'' in 2009.<ref name="introducing276">{{cite book |title=Introducing HTML5 |author1=Bruce Lawson |author2=Remy Sharp |section=Introducing Polyfills |pages=[https://books.google.com/books?id=a8HQCk4pbQkC&pg=PA276 276–277]}}</ref><ref name="sharp2010">{{cite web |last=Sharp |first=Remy |title=What is a polyfill? |url=http://remysharp.com/2010/10/08/what-is-a-polyfill/ |access-date=13 January 2012}}</ref> Formally, "a shim is a [[Library (computing)|library]] that brings a new API to an older environment, using only the means of that environment."<ref name="speakingjs"/> Polyfills exactly fit this definition; the term ''shim'' was also used for early polyfills.<ref>{{cite web |quote=This piece of information makes building an HTML5 compatibility shim for IE7 far easier than had previously been assumed.|title=Mistakes, Sadness, Regret |url=http://ln.hixie.ch/?start=1201080691&count=1 |author-link=Ian Hickson |author=Ian Hickson |date=2008-01-23}}</ref> However, to Sharp ''shim'' connoted non-transparent APIs and workarounds, such as [[spacer GIF]]s for layout, sometimes known as <code>shim.gif</code>, and similar terms such as ''[[progressive enhancement]]'' and ''[[graceful degradation]]'' were not appropriate, so he invented a new term.<ref name="sharp2010"/> The term is based on the [[spackling paste|multipurpose filling paste]] brand ''[[Spackling paste#Polyfilla|Polyfilla]],'' a paste used to cover up cracks and holes in walls, and the meaning "fill in holes (in functionality) in many ([[wikt:poly-|poly-]]) ways." The word since gained popularity, particularly due to its use by [[Paul Irish]] and in [[Modernizr]] documentation.<ref name="sharp2010"/><ref>{{cite web |url=https://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |title=HTML5 Cross browser Polyfills |website=[[GitHub]] |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100928233437/http://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |archive-date=2010-09-28}}</ref>
The term is a [[neologism]], coined by Remy Sharp, who required a word that meant "replicate an API using JavaScript (or Flash or whatever) if the browser doesn’t have it natively" while co-writing the book ''Introducing HTML5'' in 2009.<ref name="introducing276">{{cite book |title=Introducing HTML5 |author1=Bruce Lawson |author2=Remy Sharp |section=Introducing Polyfills |pages=[https://books.google.com/books?id=a8HQCk4pbQkC&pg=PA276 276–277]}}</ref><ref name="sharp2010">{{cite web |last=Sharp |first=Remy |title=What is a polyfill? |date=8 October 2010 |url=https://remysharp.com/2010/10/08/what-is-a-polyfill/ |access-date=13 January 2012}}</ref> Formally, "a shim is a [[Library (computing)|library]] that brings a new API to an older environment, using only the means of that environment."<ref name="speakingjs"/> Polyfills exactly fit this definition; the term ''shim'' was also used for early polyfills.<ref>{{cite web |quote=This piece of information makes building an HTML5 compatibility shim for IE7 far easier than had previously been assumed.|title=Mistakes, Sadness, Regret |url=https://ln.hixie.ch/?start=1201080691&count=1 |author-link=Ian Hickson |author=Ian Hickson |date=2008-01-23}}</ref> However, to Sharp ''shim'' connoted non-transparent APIs and workarounds, such as [[spacer GIF]]s for layout, sometimes known as <code>shim.gif</code>, and similar terms such as ''[[progressive enhancement]]'' and ''[[graceful degradation]]'' were not appropriate, so he invented a new term.<ref name="sharp2010"/> The term is based on the [[spackling paste|multipurpose filling paste]] brand ''[[Spackling paste#Polyfilla|Polyfilla]],'' a paste used to cover up cracks and holes in walls, and the meaning "fill in holes (in functionality) in many ([[wikt:poly-|poly-]]) ways." The word has since gained popularity, particularly due to its use by [[Paul Irish]] and in [[Modernizr]] documentation.<ref name="sharp2010"/><ref>{{cite web |url=https://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |title=HTML5 Cross browser Polyfills |website=[[GitHub]] |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100928233437/http://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |archive-date=2010-09-28}}</ref>


The distinction that Sharp makes is:<ref name="introducing276"/>
The distinction that Sharp makes is:<ref name="introducing276"/>
{{blockquote|What makes a polyfill different from the techniques we have already, like a shim, is this: if you removed the polyfill script, your code would continue to work, without any changes required ''in spite of the polyfill being removed.''}}
{{blockquote|What makes a polyfill different from the techniques we have already, like a shim, is this: if you removed the polyfill script, your code would continue to work, without any changes required ''in spite of the polyfill being removed.''}}
This distinction is not drawn by other authors.<ref name="speakingjs"/> At times various other distinctions are drawn between shims, polyfills, and fallbacks, but there are no generally accepted distinctions: most consider polyfills a form of shim.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://stackoverflow.com/questions/6599815/what-is-the-difference-between-a-shim-and-a-polyfill |title=What is the difference between a shim and a polyfill?}}</ref> The term ''polyfiller'' is also occasionally found.<ref>{{cite book|title=HTML5 Developer's Cookbook|author1=Chuck Hudson |author2=Tom Leadbetter |year=2011 |page=[https://books.google.com/books?id=No4hLcrmvw8C&pg=PT121&dq=polyfiller 121]}}</ref>
This distinction is not drawn by other authors.<ref name="speakingjs"/> At times various other distinctions are drawn between shims, polyfills, and fallbacks, but there are no generally accepted distinctions: most consider polyfills a form of shim.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://stackoverflow.com/questions/6599815/what-is-the-difference-between-a-shim-and-a-polyfill |title=What is the difference between a shim and a polyfill?}}</ref> The term ''polyfiller'' is also occasionally found.<ref>{{cite book|title=HTML5 Developer's Cookbook|author1=Chuck Hudson |author2=Tom Leadbetter |year=2011 |page=[https://books.google.com/books?id=No4hLcrmvw8C&dq=polyfiller&pg=PT121 121]}}</ref>


== Examples ==
== Examples ==
{{refimprove section |date=July 2023}}

=== core-js ===
=== core-js ===
core-js<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://github.com/zloirock/core-js|title = Core-js|website = [[GitHub]]|date = 26 October 2021}}</ref> is the most popular<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.npmtrends.com/core-js-vs-core-js-pure-vs-es5-shim-vs-es6-shim-vs-airbnb-js-shims-vs-polyfill-library-vs-polyfill-service-vs-js-polyfills|title = Airbnb-js-shims vs core-js vs core-js-pure vs es5-shim vs es6-shim vs js-polyfills vs polyfill-library vs polyfill-service &#124; NPM trends}}</ref> and powerful<ref>{{cite web | url=http://kangax.github.io/compat-table/es6/#babel7corejs3 | title=ECMAScript 6 compatibility table }}</ref> JavaScript [[standard library]] polyfill. Includes polyfills for [[ECMAScript]] up to 2021: promises, symbols, collections, iterators, typed arrays, many other features, ECMAScript proposals, some cross-platform [[WHATWG]] / [[W3C]] features and proposals like <code>URL</code>. You can load only required features or use it without global namespace pollution. It can be integrated with [[Babel (compiler)|Babel]], which allows it to automatically inject required core-js modules to your code.
core-js<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://github.com/zloirock/core-js|title = Core-js|website = [[GitHub]]|date = 26 October 2021}}</ref> is one of the most popular<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.npmtrends.com/core-js-vs-core-js-pure-vs-es5-shim-vs-es6-shim-vs-airbnb-js-shims-vs-polyfill-library-vs-polyfill-service-vs-js-polyfills|title = Airbnb-js-shims vs core-js vs core-js-pure vs es5-shim vs es6-shim vs js-polyfills vs polyfill-library vs polyfill-service &#124; NPM trends}}</ref> JavaScript [[standard library]] polyfills. Includes polyfills for [[ECMAScript]] up to the latest version of the standard: promises, symbols, collections, iterators, typed arrays, many other features, ECMAScript proposals, some cross-platform [[WHATWG]] / [[W3C]] features and proposals like <code>URL</code>. You can load only required features or use it without global namespace pollution. It can be integrated with [[Babel (compiler)|Babel]], which allows it to automatically inject required core-js modules into your code.


=== HTML5 Shiv ===
=== HTML5 Shiv ===
Line 54: Line 54:


John Dyer's MediaElement.js polyfills support for <code><video></code> and <code><audio></code> elements, including the HTML5 MediaElement API, in older browsers using Flash or Silverlight plug-ins. It also provides an optional media player UI for those elements, which is consistent across all browsers.
John Dyer's MediaElement.js polyfills support for <code><video></code> and <code><audio></code> elements, including the HTML5 MediaElement API, in older browsers using Flash or Silverlight plug-ins. It also provides an optional media player UI for those elements, which is consistent across all browsers.

=== Polyfill.io ===
A JavaScript library created by Andrew Betts that implemented Polyfill. In February 2024, the library's domain was acquired by China-based company Funnull and within a few months became part of a supply chain attack.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Goodin |first=Dan |date=2024-07-03 |title=384,000 sites pull code from sketchy code library recently bought by Chinese firm |url=https://arstechnica.com/security/2024/07/384000-sites-link-to-code-library-caught-performing-supply-chain-attack/ |access-date=2024-07-03 |website=[[Ars Technica]] |language=en-us}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |title=Polyfill.io Attack Infects Over 110,000 Websites - Spiceworks |url=https://www.spiceworks.com/it-security/cyber-risk-management/news/polyfill-supply-chain-attack-infects-websites/ |access-date=2024-07-01 |website=Spiceworks Inc |language=en-US}}</ref>


=== BrowserID ===
=== BrowserID ===
{{Main articles|Mozilla Persona}}
{{Main articles|Mozilla Persona}}
Authentication protocol proposed by Mozilla, failed to gain traction.<ref>{{ cite web | title = navigator.id | url = https://developer.mozilla.org/en/DOM/navigator.id | publisher = Mozilla Developer Network | date = 30 June 2012 }}</ref>
Authentication protocol proposed by Mozilla, failed to gain traction.<ref>{{cite web | title = navigator.id | url = https://developer.mozilla.org/en/DOM/navigator.id | publisher = Mozilla Developer Network | date = 30 June 2012 | access-date = 9 July 2012 | archive-date = 3 August 2012 | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20120803093440/https://developer.mozilla.org/en/DOM/navigator.id | url-status = dead }}</ref>


=== Webshims Lib ===
=== Webshims Lib ===
Line 64: Line 67:


=== Hyphenopoly.js ===
=== Hyphenopoly.js ===
Hyphenopoly.js enables [[Syllabification#Algorithm|automatic hyphenatation]] if it is not already supported by the browser for the respective document language.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://github.com/mnater/Hyphenopoly|title = Hyphenopoly.js|website = [[GitHub]]|date = 25 September 2022}}</ref>
Hyphenopoly.js enables [[Syllabification#Algorithm|automatic hyphenation]] if it is not already supported by the browser for the respective document language.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://github.com/mnater/Hyphenopoly|title = Hyphenopoly.js|website = [[GitHub]]|date = 25 September 2022}}</ref>


== See also ==
== See also ==
Line 81: Line 84:
== External links ==
== External links ==
* {{cite web |url= https://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |title= List of polyfills providing HTML5 facilities |location= GitHub |publisher= [[Modernizr]] project }}
* {{cite web |url= https://github.com/Modernizr/Modernizr/wiki/HTML5-Cross-browser-Polyfills |title= List of polyfills providing HTML5 facilities |location= GitHub |publisher= [[Modernizr]] project }}
* {{cite web |url= http://html5please.com/ |title= HTML5 Polyfill List by Feature |editor1-first= Divya |editor1-last= Manian |editor2-first= Paul |editor2-last= Irish |editor-link2= Paul Irish |editor3-first= Tim |editor3-last= Branyen |editor4-first= Connor |editor4-last= Montgomery |editor5-first= Arthur |editor5-last= Verschaeve |display-editors=etal |website= HTML5 Please |quote= The recommendations... represent the collective knowledge of developers who have been deep in the HTML5 trenches }}
* {{cite web |url= https://html5please.com/ |title= HTML5 Polyfill List by Feature |editor1-first= Divya |editor1-last= Manian |editor2-first= Paul |editor2-last= Irish |editor-link2= Paul Irish |editor3-first= Tim |editor3-last= Branyen |editor4-first= Connor |editor4-last= Montgomery |editor5-first= Arthur |editor5-last= Verschaeve |display-editors=etal |website= HTML5 Please |quote= The recommendations... represent the collective knowledge of developers who have been deep in the HTML5 trenches }}
* {{cite web |url= http://www.moreonfew.com/what-are-polyfills-in-javascript/ |title= What are PolyFills in Javascript? |date= Sep 5, 2013 |website= More on Few }}
* {{cite web |url= https://www.moreonfew.com/what-are-polyfills-in-javascript/ |title= What are PolyFills in Javascript? |date= Sep 5, 2013 |website= More on Few }}


[[Category:Compatibility layers]]
[[Category:Compatibility layers]]

Latest revision as of 21:25, 3 July 2024

In software development, a polyfill is code that implements a feature of the development environment that does not natively support the feature. Most often, it refers to JavaScript code that implements an HTML5 or CSS web standard, either an established standard (supported by some browsers) on older browsers, or a proposed standard (not supported by any browsers) on existing browsers. Polyfills are also used in PHP and Python.[1]

Polyfills allow web developers to use an API regardless of whether or not it is supported by a browser, and usually with minimal overhead. Typically they first check if a browser supports an API, and use it if available, otherwise using their own implementation.[2][3] Polyfills themselves use other, more supported features, and thus different polyfills may be needed for different browsers. The term is also used as a verb: polyfilling is providing a polyfill for a feature.

Definition[edit]

The term is a neologism, coined by Remy Sharp, who required a word that meant "replicate an API using JavaScript (or Flash or whatever) if the browser doesn’t have it natively" while co-writing the book Introducing HTML5 in 2009.[4][5] Formally, "a shim is a library that brings a new API to an older environment, using only the means of that environment."[2] Polyfills exactly fit this definition; the term shim was also used for early polyfills.[6] However, to Sharp shim connoted non-transparent APIs and workarounds, such as spacer GIFs for layout, sometimes known as shim.gif, and similar terms such as progressive enhancement and graceful degradation were not appropriate, so he invented a new term.[5] The term is based on the multipurpose filling paste brand Polyfilla, a paste used to cover up cracks and holes in walls, and the meaning "fill in holes (in functionality) in many (poly-) ways." The word has since gained popularity, particularly due to its use by Paul Irish and in Modernizr documentation.[5][7]

The distinction that Sharp makes is:[4]

What makes a polyfill different from the techniques we have already, like a shim, is this: if you removed the polyfill script, your code would continue to work, without any changes required in spite of the polyfill being removed.

This distinction is not drawn by other authors.[2] At times various other distinctions are drawn between shims, polyfills, and fallbacks, but there are no generally accepted distinctions: most consider polyfills a form of shim.[8] The term polyfiller is also occasionally found.[9]

Examples[edit]

core-js[edit]

core-js[10] is one of the most popular[11] JavaScript standard library polyfills. Includes polyfills for ECMAScript up to the latest version of the standard: promises, symbols, collections, iterators, typed arrays, many other features, ECMAScript proposals, some cross-platform WHATWG / W3C features and proposals like URL. You can load only required features or use it without global namespace pollution. It can be integrated with Babel, which allows it to automatically inject required core-js modules into your code.

HTML5 Shiv[edit]

In IE versions prior to 9, unknown HTML elements like <section> and <nav> would be parsed as empty elements, breaking the page's nesting structure and making those elements impossible to style using CSS. One of the most widely used polyfills, html5shiv,[a] exploits another quirk of IE to work around this bug: calling document.createElement("tagname") for each of the new HTML5 elements, which causes IE to parse them correctly. It also includes basic default styling for those HTML5 elements.

-prefix-free[edit]

Though most polyfills target out-of-date browsers, some exist to simply push modern browsers forward a little bit more. Lea Verou's -prefix-free polyfill is such a polyfill, allowing current browsers to recognise the unprefixed versions of several CSS3 properties instead of requiring the developer to write out all the vendor prefixes. It reads the page's stylesheets and replaces any unprefixed properties with their prefixed counterparts recognised by the current browser.

Selectivizr[edit]

Keith Clark's Selectivizr is a popular polyfill that makes many CSS3 selectors work in IE 8 and below. It reads the page's stylesheets looking for a number of known CSS3 selectors, then uses a JavaScript selector library to query the document for elements matching those selectors, applying the styles directly to those elements. It supports several JavaScript selector libraries such as jQuery.

Flexie[edit]

Possibly one of the most anticipated features of CSS3, Flexible Box Layout (a.k.a. Flexbox) promises to be an extremely powerful tool for laying out interface elements. WebKit and Mozilla engines have supported a preliminary draft syntax for years. Flexie implements support for that same syntax in IE and Opera. However, the draft spec has undergone a drastic revision to a new (and much more powerful) syntax, which is not yet supported by Flexie. Flexie can still be used along with the old syntax, but the developer must make sure they include the new syntax for future browsers as well.

CSS3 PIE[edit]

PIE ("Progressive Internet Explorer") implements some of the most popular missing CSS3 box decoration properties in IE, including border-radius and box-shadow for IE 8 and below, and linear-gradient backgrounds for IE 9 and below. Invoked as a HTC behavior (a proprietary IE feature), it looks for the unsupported CSS3 properties on specific elements and renders those properties using VML for IE 6–8 and SVG for IE 9. Its rendering is mostly indistinguishable from native browser implementations and it handles dynamic DOM modification well.

JSON 2[edit]

Douglas Crockford originally wrote json2.js as an API for reading and writing his (then up-and-coming) JSON data format. It became so widely used that browser vendors decided to implement its API natively and turn it into a de facto standard; Since json2.js now implements features native to newer browsers into older browsers, it has become a polyfill instead of a library.

es5-shim[edit]

ECMAScript 5th Edition ("ES5") brings some useful new scripting features, and since they're syntactically compatible with older JavaScript engines they can mostly be polyfilled by patching methods onto built-in JS objects. This es5-shim polyfill does it in two parts: es5-shim.js contains those methods that can be fully polyfilled, and es5-sham.js contains partial implementations of the other methods which rely too much on the underlying engine to work accurately.

FlashCanvas[edit]

FlashCanvas is an implementation of the HTML5 Canvas API using an Adobe Flash plug-in. A rare commercial polyfill, it comes in a paid version, as well as a free version, which lacks a few advanced features like shadows.

MediaElement.js[edit]

John Dyer's MediaElement.js polyfills support for <video> and <audio> elements, including the HTML5 MediaElement API, in older browsers using Flash or Silverlight plug-ins. It also provides an optional media player UI for those elements, which is consistent across all browsers.

Polyfill.io[edit]

A JavaScript library created by Andrew Betts that implemented Polyfill. In February 2024, the library's domain was acquired by China-based company Funnull and within a few months became part of a supply chain attack.[12][13]

BrowserID[edit]

Authentication protocol proposed by Mozilla, failed to gain traction.[14]

Webshims Lib[edit]

Alexander Farkas's Webshims Lib aggregates many other polyfills together into a single package and conditionally loads only those needed by the visiting browser.

Hyphenopoly.js[edit]

Hyphenopoly.js enables automatic hyphenation if it is not already supported by the browser for the respective document language.[15]

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ The use of the term shiv here is a pun or mistake on shim.[4]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Thormeier, Pascal (2023-06-09). Mastering CSS Grid: A comprehensive and practical guide to creating beautiful layouts with CSS Grid. Packt Publishing Ltd. p. 195. ISBN 978-1-80461-616-1.
  2. ^ a b c Luis Ángel Pérez Castillo (2019). Speaking JavaScript.
  3. ^ "It typically checks if a browser supports an API. If it doesn’t, the polyfill installs its own implementation. That allows you to use the API in either case."
  4. ^ a b c Bruce Lawson; Remy Sharp. "Introducing Polyfills". Introducing HTML5. pp. 276–277.
  5. ^ a b c Sharp, Remy (8 October 2010). "What is a polyfill?". Retrieved 13 January 2012.
  6. ^ Ian Hickson (2008-01-23). "Mistakes, Sadness, Regret". This piece of information makes building an HTML5 compatibility shim for IE7 far easier than had previously been assumed.
  7. ^ "HTML5 Cross browser Polyfills". GitHub. Archived from the original on 2010-09-28.
  8. ^ "What is the difference between a shim and a polyfill?".
  9. ^ Chuck Hudson; Tom Leadbetter (2011). HTML5 Developer's Cookbook. p. 121.
  10. ^ "Core-js". GitHub. 26 October 2021.
  11. ^ "Airbnb-js-shims vs core-js vs core-js-pure vs es5-shim vs es6-shim vs js-polyfills vs polyfill-library vs polyfill-service | NPM trends".
  12. ^ Goodin, Dan (2024-07-03). "384,000 sites pull code from sketchy code library recently bought by Chinese firm". Ars Technica. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  13. ^ "Polyfill.io Attack Infects Over 110,000 Websites - Spiceworks". Spiceworks Inc. Retrieved 2024-07-01.
  14. ^ "navigator.id". Mozilla Developer Network. 30 June 2012. Archived from the original on 3 August 2012. Retrieved 9 July 2012.
  15. ^ "Hyphenopoly.js". GitHub. 25 September 2022.

External links[edit]