User:Bermicourt/Portal status
Appearance
(Redirected from Wikipedia:WikiProject Portals/Evaluation)
Notes on evaluating portals
[edit]When you evaluate a portal, please always add the date (month/year), version and your name ([[User:XYZ|XYZ]] or ~~~~~ (3*); please do not use ~~~~ (4*) for reasons of space, since it contains an element that cannot be checked or queried. It also stops portals from being self-evaluated. Assessments are part of a review process. They are therefore to be taken as advice and not as mandatory instructions which must be acted upon. The overall assessment should logically follow from the remarks. The following criteria should be used for evaluation:
Overall evaluation
[edit]- Principles
- A portal that has neither a nominated editor or editors nor a WikiProject or Task Force overseeing it, can be rated no higher than
.
- A portal under construction may be rated
until it is ready. If it is still incomplete after a month, it should be rated
- Nominated 'overseer' editors who have been inactive for more than six months may be removed.
- Colour key
Good: rule of thumb: a portal is only assessed as "green" if none of the individual evaluation criteria are "red" and there are significantly more criteria rated as "green" than "yellow".
Adequate: generally ok, but has minor issues
Poor: has medium to serious issues. The rule of thumb is that if more of the detailed criteria are assessed as "red" than "green" or if there are more than three "reds", then the overall rating should be red.
: Under construction.
- Status key
under review
being created or under construction
featured portal candidate, see criteria
featured portal
re-running featured portal candidates
being considered for deletion
Detailed assessment
[edit]
|
See also
[edit]- Wikipedia:WikiProject Portals/Status
- User:Bermicourt/Portal/Overview and Relevance
- User:Bermicourt/Portals
- Template:Portal-Info
- Template:Portal-Info-Intro
- Template:WikiProject Portals/New
- Template:Wertung
Source
[edit]This page was edited to contain a total or partial translation of Wikipedia:WikiProjekt Portale/Bewertung from the German Wikipedia. Consult the history of the original page to see a list of its authors. (This notice applies to version 838656496 and subsequent versions of this page.) |