Wikipedia

Medical fiction

Medical fiction is fiction whose events center upon a hospital, an ambulance staff, or any medical environment. It is highly prevalent on television, especially as medical dramas, as well as in novels.

The depiction of medical institutions and their staff has been considered important both for the influence it has on the perception of their real counterparts, and the role it can play in medical education.[1][2][3] Through their personal or collective experiences with specific diseases, medical institutions, and health professionals, the audience can relate to the situations depicted in medical fiction, contributing to the success of the genre. This familiarity with the subject matter requires a degree of realism in order "to avoid misinterpretations or false ideas about the medical institutional or professional practice".[1][4]

Medical fiction also allows "the illustration and discussion of ethical dilemmas that are frequently not raised for reasons of discretion, embarrassment, or fear of retribution" in the scientific community.[5]

The Babyland General Hospital is a different type of fiction in the form of an actual building, where the procedure of birth and adoption is played out with Cabbage Patch Kids dolls in a converted former hospital.[6][7][8]

Alternatively, the term may refer to Narrative Medicine—stories written by medical professionals to help foster empathy and humanize the practice of medicine.[9]

History

edit

Given the importance of healing and bodily transformations in general literature itself, the history of medical fiction arguably extends to the Greek civilization in the form of Asclepius, the ancient Greek god of medicine. In myth, and in the general understanding of the Greek people, the god was said to heal individuals through his temple priests.[10]

One of the most well-known examples of medical fiction in dramaturgy is The Imaginary Invalid, written by Molière. The satire-comedy focuses on the medical profession and has a hypochondriac for its main character. The play lampoons the society of late 17th-century Paris, specifically the bourgeoisie, and is generally considered a piece of incisive social commentary.[11]

One of, if not the earliest examples of science fiction can be found in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. The novel itself concerns the abominable creation of Dr. Victor Frankenstein as the character attempts to circumvent death through the creation of life. As a medical fiction text, it explores several ethical themes, such as the role of a doctor as the preserver of life, the ethics of attempting to create life in unnatural ways, and the logical extremes of playing God.

An 1889 entry from the British Medical Journal seems to mark a societal shift in England by where doctors began to gain a higher status in society, and reflects on the historical practice of satirizing medical practitioners through the work of authors like Laurence Sterne, Henry Fielding, and Tobias Smollett.[12] Four years later, the same journal would participate in the tradition of questioning medical accuracy in fiction, beginning by citing a request from Mark Twain to lecture on chemistry before the Royal Society, followed by a cursory dissection of various medical inaccuracies in, at the time, contemporary works of fiction.[13]

The 1900s by and large saw the rise of the "doctor novel" as a literary subgenre, which itself is a subset of, or otherwise synonymous with, medical fiction.[14]

A 2009 book, Doctors in Fiction: Lessons from Literature, discusses medical practitioners ranging from the late 12th century to the early 21st, including small analyzes of their particular time periods.[15]

Criticism

edit

Concerns have been raised by medical professionals regarding inaccuracies present in medical dramas, citing unrealistic expectations that they may impose on viewers in relation to rapid response times and unconventional treatment at emergency rooms.[16] These issues have been compounded by depictions of unprofessional behavior in shows like House (TV series), which, coupled with depictions of incorrect medical procedures, are said to have the possibility of imprinting negatively on medical students; nevertheless, critics and instructors argue these episodes might be used in academic settings to foster discussions on ethics, malpractice, and proper doctor-patient relationships.[17]

Regarding medical novels, similar criticisms of artistic liberties and inaccuracies have been levied, but nevertheless grant that the literature might increase interest in the medical field and its history.[18] In addition, attention has been directed towards the use of fiction as a useful tool for bioethicists to understand atypical and criminal behavior, such as the numerous murders by serial killer Harold Shipman.[19]

Subgenres

edit
  • Romance novels have an independent subcategory in medicine, medical romance, with its own settings and characters.[20]
  • Doctor novel[20]
  • Medical crime or conspiracy
  • Medical research fiction[20]
  • Medical thriller
  • Medical comedy
  • Psychiatry in fiction[21][22]
  • Medical science fiction
  • Medical poetry

Medical romance

edit

ABC's Grey's Anatomy is a medical drama that employs the use of medical romance heavily throughout its narrative. The series follows the life and medical practice of the titular Meredith Grey as she balances her own personal life with the demanding stress of hospital bureaucracy and practice. Beginning in 2005 and currently still in production in 2024, the series became the longest running medical drama in 2019.[23]

Medical Research Fiction

edit

Medical research also features frequently in fiction.[20] In contrast to medical treatment it is depicted in an ambivalent or negative way in many cases. Often associated with future developments, testing of ethical boundaries, especially with regard to experimentation on living subjects, is a common topic and gives expression to "deep-seated fears and expectations connected to our own lives".[24] Notable examples are the mysterious Dharma Initiative from the TV series Lost, which follows a nefarious plan to influence humanity and employs characters of the mad scientist type,[25] and Project Cadmus from DC Comics, a shady agency conducting genetic experiments disregarding any ethical boundaries.[26] On the contrary S.T.A.R. Labs, also from DC Comics, is a research organization providing medical assistance to the heroes of the stories. So it is depicted in a generally positive light, but that presentation is foiled by a number of individual members conducting unethical experiments.[27]

Medical thriller

edit

The film Coma directed by Michael Crichton is a pioneer of the medical thriller.

Netflix's Ratched follows Nurse Ratched, the same character from One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. The series explores her dark past and less-than-scrupulous behavior as a nurse, often employing murder and deceit to manipulate those around her in order to achieve her aims. The series appears to also humanize a typically unfavorably-viewed fictional character through the use of Ratched as a protagonist.[28] As a medical piece, it explores themes of medical malpractice for personal gain and the perversion of conventional roles of healing.

Medical comedy

edit

One of the most prominent examples of medical comedy is the American sitcom, Scrubs. The sitcom follows three medical interns on their journey through internship, residency, and ultimately become fully-fledged doctors. Often praised for its authenticity, the series occasionally tackled serious issues like infected organ donations, acceptance of death, and moral dilemmas.[29] The series was nominated for over 17 Emmys, of which it won two.[30]

Psychiatry in Fiction

edit

Settings treating mental health issues are frequently portrayed negatively in fiction.[31][32] In fiction depicting mental health institutions, like the film One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, revolt of the characters against control exercised by the institution is a common theme.[33] Another notable example is the Arkham Asylum for the Criminally Insane in Batman comics: Hearkening back to the works of H. P. Lovecraft, it incorporates the "willful misremembering of historical madhouse regimes" into a contemporary setting, outwardly symbolized by a gothic-style building. It is a problematic depiction of mental illness as it both "trivializes the experience of going "mad"" and "demonstrates little interest in the actual workings of such institutions".[34][32]

Medical science fiction

edit

Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go (novel) has been hailed as a dark, dystopian vision of a world where clones are used as organ harvesting farms. The book raises important medical themes about the personhood and agency of clones, layered with coming-of-age experiences that illustrate said personhood.[35] The piece has also been used to analyze issues of quality of life and how vocational work can help contextualize and process grief.[36]

An example of medical science fiction can be found in the science-fiction television episode "Ethics" in Star Trek: The Next Generation, in which one of the characters has his spinal cord replaced on a space station with a new one.[37] In another case, the television episode "Babel" in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine mentions aphasia—a real life disorder—brought on by a virus.[38] Aphasia concerns the "inability to understand or use written or spoken words," and is caused by a brain injury such as from a stroke, tumor, or infection.[39]

Medical Poetry

edit

Anthony Hecht's poem, The Transparent Man, focuses on the patient experience of undergoing chemotherapy and the rationalization of death that may accompany the contraction of cancer.

Admission, Children's Unit is a poem written by Theodore Deppe that chronicles the treating of a child with cigarette burns on his body, inflicted by his mother's boyfriend. The poem deals with themes of religion and domestic abuse, and the nurse's reconciliation of the experience with his own recollection of St. Lawrence which he heard in high school.[40]

See also

edit

Further reading

edit
  • Surawicz, Borys; Jacobson, Beverly (2009). Doctors in Fiction: Lessons from Literature. Radcliffe Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84619-328-6.

References

edit
  1. ^ a b Comelles, Josep M.; Brigidi, Serena (2014). "Fictional encounters and real engagements: the representation of medical practice and institutions in Medical TV shows". Actes d'història de la ciència i de la tècnica. 7 (7): 17–34. doi:10.2436/20.2006.01.182. Retrieved January 6, 2022.
  2. ^ Stinson, Mary Elizabeth; Heischmidt, Kenneth (2012). "Patients' perceptions of physicians: a pilot study of the influence of prime-time fictional medical shows". Health Marketing Quarterly. 29 (1): 66–81. doi:10.1080/07359683.2012.652579. PMID 22416926. S2CID 13483705.
  3. ^ Hoffman, Beth L.; Hoffman, Robert; Wessel, Charles B.; Shensa, Ariel; Wood, Michelle S.; Primack, Brian A. (2018). "Use of fictional medical television in health sciences education: a systematic review". Advances in Health Sciences Education. 23 (1): 201–216. doi:10.1007/s10459-017-9754-5. PMID 28083814. S2CID 46842723.
  4. ^ Collee, John (April 10, 1999). "Medical fiction: Should be accurate, but need not be didactic". British Medical Journal. 318 (7189): 955–956. doi:10.1136/bmj.318.7189.955. PMC 1115404. PMID 10195950.
  5. ^ Djerassi, Carl (June 11, 1998). "Ethical discourse by science-in-fiction" (PDF). Commentary. Nature. 393 (6685): 511–513. Bibcode:1998Natur.393..511D. doi:10.1038/31088. PMID 9634224. S2CID 4778534. Retrieved January 17, 2022.
  6. ^ "Cleveland's Cabbage Patch Kids turn 25". AccessNorthGA.com. 2008-09-07. Retrieved January 31, 2022.
  7. ^ Williams, Joy (2001). "The Case Against Babies". In Ratner, Rochelle (ed.). Bearing Life: Women's Writings on Childlessness. Feminist Press. pp. 78–79. ISBN 1-55861-275-0.
  8. ^ Vollmer, Matthew (2014). "This World Is Not Your Home". Ploughshares. 40 (4): 127–140. doi:10.1353/plo.2014.0067. hdl:10919/107207. S2CID 161722863.
  9. ^ Johna, Samir; Rahman, Simi (2011). "Humanity before Science: Narrative Medicine, Clinical Practice, and Medical Education". The Permanente Journal. 15 (4): 92–94. doi:10.7812/TPP/11-111. ISSN 1552-5767. PMC 3267572. PMID 22319427.
  10. ^ Hart, Gerald D. (1965-01-30). "Asclepius, God of Medicine". Canadian Medical Association Journal. 92 (5): 232–236. ISSN 0008-4409. PMC 1927741. PMID 14246298.
  11. ^ Learning, Gale, Cengage (2016). A Study Guide for Moliere's "The Imaginary Invalid". Gale, Cengage Learning. ISBN 978-1-4103-4927-9.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  12. ^ "Medical Men In Fiction. I". The British Medical Journal. 1 (1478): 953–955. 1889. ISSN 0007-1447. JSTOR 20219496.
  13. ^ "Medicine In Fiction". The British Medical Journal. 2 (1644): 32–33. 1892. ISSN 0007-1447. JSTOR 20246666.
  14. ^ Scott, Phillip A. (1992). The Medical Research Novel in English and German, 1900-1950. Popular Press. ISBN 978-0-87972-552-5.
  15. ^ "Doctors in Fiction: Lessons from Literature". medhum.med.nyu.edu. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  16. ^ Manfredini, R. (1999-10-23). "Medical fiction could be misleading". BMJ. 319 (7217): 1132. doi:10.1136/bmj.319.7217.1132. ISSN 0959-8138. PMC 1116913. PMID 10531115.
  17. ^ Weaver, Roslyn; Wilson, Ian (2011-01-01). "Scrubs, House, Grey's Anatomy: are medical students learning bad habits?". Faculty of Science, Medicine and Health - Papers: Part A: 1–4.
  18. ^ Spray, Ms (2019-12-05). "A novel approach to the history of medicine: a look at the relationship between fiction and medical history". Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh. 49 (4): 336–343. doi:10.4997/JRCPE.2019.418. PMID 31808465. S2CID 208744047. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  19. ^ Hurwitz, Brian (2015). "Medical humanities and medical alterity in fiction and in life". Journal of Medical Ethics. 41 (1): 64–67. doi:10.1136/medethics-2014-102300. ISSN 0306-6800. JSTOR 43283227. PMC 5146638. PMID 25516938.
  20. ^ a b c d Scott, Philipp A. (1992) The medical research novel in English and German, 1900-1950. Popular Press, ISBN 0-87972-552-4
  21. ^ Surawicz, Borys; Jacobson, Beverly (2009). "Novel Psychiatrists". Doctors in Fiction: Lessons from Literature. Radcliffe Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84619-328-6.
  22. ^ Brandell, Jerrold R., ed. (2004). Celluloid Couches, Cinematic Clients: Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy in the Movies. Albany: State University of New York Press. ISBN 0-7914-6081-9.
  23. ^ Lisa Respers France (2019-03-01). "'Grey's Anatomy' just made history". CNN. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  24. ^ Weingart, Peter; Muhl, Claudia; Pansegrau, Petra (July 1, 2003). "Of Power Maniacs and Unethical Geniuses: Science and Scientists in Fiction Film". Public Understanding of Science. 13 (3): 279–287. doi:10.1177/0963662503123006. S2CID 146784823.
  25. ^ Larsen, Kristine (2011). "Frankenstein's Legacy: The Mad Scientist Remade". In Heit, Jamey (ed.). Vader, Voldemort and Other Villains: Essays on Evil in Popular Media. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Company. pp. 48–53. ISBN 978-0-7864-5845-5.
  26. ^ Dyce, Andrew (18 October 2016). "Supergirl: Project Cadmus Mysteries Explained". Screen Rant. Retrieved January 24, 2022. Over the years, the group became officially known as Project Cadmus, and made genetic research, hybridization, and exploration their specialty.
  27. ^ Dougall, Alastair; Ridout, Cefn, eds. (2021). The DC Comics Encyclopedia. Penguin Random House. p. 265. ISBN 978-0-24143-953-1.
  28. ^ Syme, Rachel (19 September 2020). ""Ratched," Reviewed: A Confused, Caricaturish Origin Story for the "Cuckoo's Nest" Villainess". The New Yorker. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  29. ^ "Scrubs: 15 Saddest Moments, Ranked". ScreenRant. 2019-06-23. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  30. ^ "Scrubs". Television Academy. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
  31. ^ Dudley, Michael (1994). "Images of psychiatry in recent Australian and New Zealand fiction". Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry. 28 (4): 574–590. doi:10.1080/00048679409080781. PMID 7794201. S2CID 34107560. Retrieved February 4, 2022.
  32. ^ a b Ellis, Jason W. (2020). "Foreword". In Packer, Sharon; Fredrick, Daniel R. (eds.). Welcome to Arkham Asylum: Essays on Psychiatry and the Gotham City Institution. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Company. p. 1. ISBN 978-1-4766-7098-0.
  33. ^ Pheasant-Kelly, Frances (2013). "Introduction: Institutions, Abjection and Subjectivity". Abject Spaces in American Cinema. Oxford: I.B. Tauris. ISBN 978-1-84885-597-7.
  34. ^ Noad, Benjamin (2021). ""His Madness held no affinity": Reimagining Arkham Asylum". Studies in Gothic Fiction. 7: 41–50. doi:10.18573/sgf.51 (inactive 1 November 2024). Archived from the original on June 18, 2022. Retrieved February 4, 2022.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of November 2024 (link)
  35. ^ McDonald, Keith (2007). "Days of Past Futures: Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go as "Speculative Memoir"". Biography. 30 (1): 74–83. doi:10.1353/bio.2007.0025. ISSN 1529-1456. S2CID 161646026.
  36. ^ Eatough, Matthew (2011). "The Time that Remains: Organ Donation, Temporal Duration, and Bildung in Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go". Literature and Medicine. 29 (1): 132–160. doi:10.1353/lm.2011.0312. ISSN 1080-6571. PMID 21954667. S2CID 9262722.
  37. ^ Nemecek, Larry (2012-09-25). The Next Generation Companion: Star Trek The Next Generation. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 978-1-4711-0679-8.
  38. ^ Ayers, Jeff (2006-12-29). Voyages of Imagination: The Star Trek Fiction Companion. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 978-1-4165-2548-6.
  39. ^ Aphasia. National Institutes of Health. 1983.
  40. ^ "Admission, Children's Unit". medhum.med.nyu.edu. Retrieved 2021-04-23.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Medical_fiction&oldid=1254933451"