Hmm, I deleted the only one and installed the new one but it still seems to only bring up Monitor 2, no matter where the mouse is or which monitor the focused window is on. I have tried it with no windows open as well, and it still just grabs the second one. The other strange thing is that it pulls up the interface on my main monitor now, so it obviously is correctly making use of the monitors. I greatly appreciate you trying to resolve this, please let me know if there's anything else I can try on my end to help you out.