Hey, no kink shaming ;-)
But seriously, it seems for any thing that is a sexual thing, there are people that hate it and people that love it. NTR as it is called currently, induces strong feelings. So those that do not like it, are often activly repulsed by it and not only indifferent.
And one should never forget that this is games and not the real deal. Just because you like to watch for example gang-bang pron does not mean you want to participate in a real one. Same principle as shooter games.